Admin, Ideas - Written by Bob Walsh on Wednesday, July 18, 2007 16:35 - 16 Comments
Why Open Source sucks and why microISVs should fix it (Money!)
by Bob Walsh
“I rant, therefore I am.”
Dennis Miller quotes (American Comedian and Actor, b.1953)
I’ve just spent a free, all-expenses-paid, 2 day vacation in Open Source Tech Support Hell, and I am not a happy camper.
The problems started Monday when for no apparent reason, 47hats. com copy of the Open Source blog publishing package WordPress started truncating posts in the RSS feed after the first 2-3 lines.
Before ranting on about this, I want to thank Nick Bradbury, Mike Rohde, Nick Hebb, Michael Nebinger, Andy Brice, Martin, Thunderbird, and most of all Dave Elkins for alerting me to the problem and coming to my aid. Through the kind help of friends, Net buddies and kind passerbys, I was finally able to fix this damned issue.
And that’s precisely the problem. When my car breaks down, I don’t interrupt my friends to get them to fix it - I call AAA that I pay for. And when my PC or Mac starts acting weird, I don’t ask my friends to fix it - I use the tech support I prepaid for, or my carefully horded stock of Microsoft Empower support hours, or go buy a utility program like TechTool Pro that’s sitting next to this Mac to be installed.
I don’t knit my own clothes, make my own shoes, cut my own lumber, hunt for my own food or smelt my own steel. People give me these bits of data or paper called Money for what I can do for them; I give the same bits to all those other people out there I need stuff and services from. Seems to work out.
I wanted to give some of my money to someone - anyone - to make my WordPress problem go away. I really, really did. So I went to the fount of all WordPress collective wisdom, the WordPress Support Forums, figuring there must be someone there who has solved this problem and for a reasonable amount of bucks would make the problem go away.
Instead I got introduced to Section F. That’s Section Fracked of the WordPress Forum Rules. The Rules say in part,
“Remember - WordPress is FREE software.” and the further down, the infamous Section F:
F: Paying for services
Requesting paid help is discouraged. We do not want to give any impression that WordPress help is anything but free. We also do not need bidding wars in the forums.
If you have posted some contact information your thread will be closed.
If you have not posted that information we will ask you to and when you do the thread will be closed.
Any thread that offers any service for money can be closed at any time. We are not against paid services but these forums are not the right place for them.
We have a WP-Pro mailing list which you are encouraged to use.
http://lists.automattic.com/mailman/listinfo/wp-pro.
A mailing list?? I might as well rub two sticks together and make smoke signals.
And by turns we arrive at what’s wrong with Open Source, how it can be fixed, and why microISVs should do the fixing.
Once long ago, when magical beasts and guys in white shirts, short haircuts and pocket protectors roamed the earth, a hearty band of fellows (no girls allowed) came together for the sheer love of programming to create code anyone could see, change and use without sullying their hands with the coin of the realm. They created wonderful things like Firefox, Linux and yes, WordPress.
Then the Dark Times came, and their pristine land became an information superhighway of crass mercantilism, strip malls and money, money, money everywhere.
Those pure of heart retreated to their sanctuaries of non-commercialism, but live on in legend, IRC chat rooms and mailing lists, secure in the knowledge they have done good without the bastardization of their noble ideals and ideas by the debasement of accepting money for their work, surviving on a diet of alms, guilt money from dot-com millionaires, and the occasional corporate inflow.
Hey guys, what’s wrong with making a buck? I’m proud when I do - and not proud when I don’t (not to mention stressed, frustrated and fearful). What in the hell is wrong with saying, “help me and I will pay you money”? Especially when there are a few million people out there that weren’t part of your merry band of contributors who now rely on the great tools you made and who Want To Pay You Money because they are great tools? Sheesh.
Enter microISVs, stage right. There is a huge opportunity out there for at least a couple dozen microISVs to write “Registry Cleaner” apps that the Great Unwashed like me could buy to deal with our Open Source woes. If I could have found an app that was a database of the common WordPress problems updated quarterly as a subscription, or a tool that would feed my RSS URLs through a validator like Feed Validator and then tell me in simple words what the hell to do, I would have happily given you money.
“But all he had to do was go to the Support Forum, or check read the code, or wait patiently for someone in a few months to get around to his issue,” the sackclothed Open Source adherents will cry. Been there, done that, got zip. I don’t want to learn your stinking codebase, read a thousand support forums posts or even learn your Evil language - I just want my problem fixed. Is that really too much to ask? Would WordPress really suffer if it’s high priests got the hems of their white togas a little dirty by allowing posts like Can someone help me for cash?!! in some little corner of their realm?
The point I am trying to make in this Rant is that we now live in a world of great Open Source software with support and utilities aftermarket that completely suck, or commercial software that while not as pure at least gets sold by large companies that have to at least pretend to support their products, and small companies that actually do.
What the world needs now isn’t love, sweet love, its a bunch of very hungry and imaginative microISVs to monetize the support of Open Source apps we’ve all come to depend on via software and service. Let those who for the pure love of what they do continue to write great code; meanwhile the rest of us want support, services and apps we can buy that makes problems go away.
Send me your first copy of “WordPress Cleaner”, won’t you? I’ve got a finger just itching to press the Buy Now! button.
[tags]Open Source, WordPress, microISVs[/tags]
Popularity: 2% [?]
16 Comments
Okay, point taken. Now, having just espoused the capitalism credo, when will we get the chance to pay you for help ? Or at least see the details of what such an arrangement might look like ?
I applaud you wanting to get it right the first time, but, I think there are plenty other tentative MicroISV(s) who would throw money at you to make their insecurities (their problems) go away.
Thanks for taking the leap into this new consultancy.
I see this as more of a rant about WordPress support rather than Open Source support in general.
There are many many open source projects that have commercial support available.
Saying that, I haven’t seen a website that lists open source projects that have commercial support.
That would be handy for people when choosing software.
Ray Smith
Bob,
That’s exactly my pet peeve with open source as well. One example of this is the server part of Subversion. The client side of Subversion is covered very well. The server side, not so well.
I had a huge pain when administrating my Subversion server on my Windows server box. I got tired of fumbling around, so I created a nice MMC snapin to manage the sever bits. I’m about to launch in about a couple months.
Using Subversion, awesome. Getting paid to support it, priceless.
Fred
So, let me sum it up:
1. You have bad experience with the approach of WordPress folks and quickly generalize it to Open Source in general. Nice thinking here.
2. You complain that there’s no way to pay for support, yet when you are pointed to the place where there *is* paid support, you dismiss it because… I don’t know, looks totally irrational to me. And you arrive to the conclusion that your dislike for writing emails is somehow *WordPress’s* fault? Come on.
Interesting article.
From a users point of view you are 100% correct - you want the support when you need it and are willing to pay for it.
Your frustration has lessons for every ISV.
Customer support is a notoriously difficult thing to get right. It is resource hungry activity that doesnt have the ’sex appeal’ that e.g. product development has - which is why so many projects (open-source and proprietary) fail to get it right.
Interestingly, many open-source projects actively encourage third-party developers to sell support as a commercial service, allowing the software to be released for free under a GPL license.
This is a relatively new space but one which I believe offers lots of opportunities for the micro-ISV community.
I agree with your religious analogy - I do think these debates are sometimes driven more by ideology than anything else.
Checkout the debate currently raging in the Joomla! CMS project around the issue of third-party developers offering proprietary extensions to the open-source CMS (http://forum.joomla.org/index.php?board=48.0) WARNING: its not pretty:)
I use a lot of open-source software and have come to realize that its a mixed bag - some projects are mature, stable software with an active support system, and some are not! either way, if you are going to use open-source then I think you have to accept that at some point you will have to pop the hood and fix the thing yourself.
BTW. I just Googled “wordpress paid for support” and found at least one solution for you on page one..
Don’t you just love this Internet thingy ![]()
John
I agree with you!
Open Software or Free Software or whatever these guys call it, it’s just SUCKS…
I have one friend at work his Open Source fan, I alwasy have argument with him about just the concept of FREE Software.
The world dosn’t need Open Software or Free Software, what the world needs is QUALITY, GOOD software, there is nothing wrong for selling your knowlage for money, all MD they do this all time and no one asks for FREE Private Doctors…
All these things about “Free as code not as beer” …I sell business solutions, how in the world I will give my customer the source code for my accounting software I sell it to him/her?? First of all “IT”S NOT WORTH IT” the customer will never care, he/she simply needs the work to get done! Nothing more, forget about the source code!!
What freedom the customer will have from giving him/her my source code!!! Is that will make him/her happy??? Or giving him my full time support and provide him with latest updates.
I’m sorry if I sound angry, in fact I am, because these guys from Open/Free Source world they want me to feel bad about myself just because I ask money for my own work! My software!
The world will not be a better place if we all go Open/Free software…the world will be a better place IF we all do a good job of whatever we’re doing in business…and provide high quality products with reasonable prices…
That’s the most important thing!
Bob,
Aren’t there any commercial blogging packages that you can use that would include paid support? Why use Word Press at all if the open-source model isn’t working for you?
–Kevin
Sid
Nick Herb -> Nick Hebb
Greg Cheong
I would like to point out that there are quite a few companies who do make money centered around providing services and derivative products for open source software (redhat, mysql come to mind) and many others selling software services based on open source software (37 signals and numerous other web base services using OSS to run their applications). So I think a better title perhaps would be “Why WordPress Sucks…”.
Cheers,
Greg
[...] Thanks for visiting!I helped Bob Walsh fix an issue with his RSS feeds in WordPress.? Here is the link. Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and [...]
Maybe they heard you
A few minutes with Google, and I found this commercial WordPress support site. http://automattic.com/services/support-network/
I would add a suggestion for a micro-ISV: build an online business around managing the technical stuff for installing blog upgrades, backing up databases, and installing new themes.
I spend way too much time doing this sort of stuff and not enough time being able to write.
On the free support: dead on. I can eventually figure it out through trial and error — the key word being “eventually.” I don’t want to spend the time and the effort to trial and error — and recover — my way to a solution. I want something fixed or done.
The world has come to free support and I now need to be an expert in everything.
Paid support: I left a hosting company because the support received was no better than the self-help files. If the paid support isn’t good, then I walk. So providing paid support has risks as most everyone loves to be cheap when support is done.
We are a self-service world. Can I flip my own burgers at McDonald’s?
Charlie
I believe you’ve got a misprint. The gentleman that operates BreezeTree is Nick Hebb, not Herb.
Thanks,
Charlie
Bob Walsh
Thanks Charlie - You’re right and it should be fixed as of now.
Bob Walsh
Ray, Fred & Kevin -
I like WordPress - I really do. And commercial (read TypePad) have issues - something disrupted their hosting service’s power this afternoon for several hours.
What got me was the holier than thou attitude of the people who run that forum - money is somehow a dirty thing and we don’t want any part of that. Fine if that works for them - but what about the rest of us?
As John pointed out, there are companies realizing there’s a need here - but so far, only for enterprise size ventures prepared to spend $5K or $10K. There’s a huge opportunity here for microISVs who can figure out a way to turn their WordPress (and other Open Source) expertise into products and services.
Leave a Reply
RSS
MicroISV Sites that Sell!
| Is your web site hurting your sales? You're are not alone. In this ebook I dig deep into how microISVs need to structure their Unique Selling Proposition in order to sell more. This 88-page ebook will help you substantially improve your microISV's sales. Buy it now, or read more here.[PayPal alternative] | |
Buy MicroISV Sites that Sell! |
![]() |
47Hats consulting services:
Alltop/startups proud contributor
Most Popular Content
- Accomplishing More By Doing Less
- MicroISV Digest
- Passing the Torch: the Micro ISV Digest
- You don’t need 1 blog: you need 3.
- Bits and Pieces
- Calling all microISVs/startups! Be on the lookout for…
- Constraints are a good thing.
- 51 Steps to Startup Success - Not!
- Bits and Pieces.
- Striking a balance of user needs in technology development.
- The law is the law.
- Bob,
Thanks for the mention. I appreciate it.
~Scott...
- The best thing about constraints is that they give you a boundary that separates...
- I made an application via this website and they didn't even bother to reply.....
- Thanks, for taking this on Bob. It's definitely a valuable resource for those of...
- Thanks Brian for the correction - That's what 12 hrs of attempting to work with ...
- Memo to self - Proofread first, post second. Sheesh!...
- @Mark Roseman: Great Idea. I recently developed my own blog with Django and buil...
- I too would like an easy way to get a feed of comments - perhaps someone reading...
47Hats shared feed
47Hats ecommerce powered by:
Follow me on Twitter
Blogging - Aug 19, 2008 16:34 - 8 Comments
You don’t need 1 blog: you need 3.
More In Marketing
- Calling all microISVs/startups! Be on the lookout for…
- Do it in front of other people.
- Product blogs don’t have to be boring.
- Here comes da Judge!
- Hard numbers about blogging and social networks.
Productivity - Aug 1, 2008 18:17 - 0 Comments
12 Tactics to stop stealing time from yourself.
More In Productivity
- 5 Strategies to stop stealing time from yourself.
- Stop stealing.
- 5 tips for focusing on your MicroISV
- With a little help from my friends…
- Peering into the New Year
Links - Aug 15, 2008 15:35 - 0 Comments
Bits and Pieces
More In Resources
- Bits and Pieces.
- Clients making news.
- Deathmarch not over; but I’m back.
- Crowdsource Testing your Application
- Admittedly completely off topic…



I thought that maybe http://www.wordpress.com would offer support, as they offer commerical hosting. I had a look at their support page and got this message:
“Support will be closed Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday while the Automattic crew gathers in San Francisco in preparation for WordCamp 2007. We will re-open Monday morning around 9AM PDT.”. LOL, point taken.
P.S. You’ve got Nick Hebb’s name wrong, the downside of spell checking?